Christmas traditions in America and England: Let’s Compare!

As with so many other things, there are far more differences than one would think between America and England. And when it comes to the Christmas holidays, this is true too! Over the past several years I’ve noticed all the little differences that add up to a very different holiday experience, and here I have compiled them for you. Ta-da!

Movies: As we Americans know, the quintessential Christmas eve films are “A Christmas Story” (you’ll shoot yer eye out!) and the classic Dr. Seuss animated version of “The Grinch Who Stole Christmas”. In the UK you get the much more staid “The Snowman”, which is mostly silent and only 30ish minutes long. Anticlimactic!

Treats for Santa: In England children leave a carrot for the reindeer, and a mince pie and some sherry (!!) for the fat man, while in the States we do cookies and milk, which seems far more wholesome if you ask me.

Songs: It seems to me that here in the UK the most popular holiday tunes  (aka, the ones I hear allllll the timmmmeeee) are a few decades old: Slade and Band Aid and The Pogues seem to be on a never-ending loop, accompanied by Wham’s “Last Christmas”.  In America I think Mariah Carey’s “All I Want For Christmas Is You” is the big song of the season, and whatever other pop songs get released each year (NSYNC and Justin Bieber and Christina Aguilera singing their remakes of classics, plus dudes like Michael Buble doing the Xmas crooning thang). It seems that these, plus a sprinkling of traditional carols, like Silent Night and all of that, make up the American musical repertoire at the holidays. And don’t forget about Nat King Cole and Bing Crosby! (America skips the past few decades and heads straight for the fifties and sixties).

and more evidence!

Christmas Eve: Traditionally Christmas eve in the UK is spent (by the young folk) down at the pub with their friends, boozing. So weird for me, since in the USA Christmas Eve is almost solely reserved for family time. It’s nice though, and it seems to me that the American version of this “hanging out with old friends from home” happens the week of Thanksgiving, and since there is no Thanksgiving in the UK you get Christmas Eve as a pub night!

Entertainment: In my mind, he holiday season equals=The Nutcracker. Here, pantomimes, also known as “pantos” are the popular seasonal entertainment. As far as I can tell since I’ve still never been to one, pantos are like interactive musical theater-very camp and silly and slapsticky. They have nothing to do with mimes! They’re seemingly popular with children and families, which is probably why I haven’t seen one with Jon. Some day!

Christmas crackers: Okay, I can’t think of an American equivalent for these! But these little party favors are center stage at every Christmas dinner, and sort of like the lucky wishbone tradition at Thanksgiving, two people give a tug on each of a cracker, and inside there’s a silly joke, a toy or treat of some sort, and a paper crown. You can buy luxury ones from places like Harrods, or cheapies at any other store on the street-there’s a huge variety of them available this time of year! The jokes inside are always unbearably cheesy, which makes them even funnier.

Meal time: Alright, this one isn’t as concrete, but it’s more a Christmas lunch in the UK, rather than Christmas dinner. Obviously this is variable.

The main event: The Christmas main course of choice in the States is generally a Christmas ham, since turkey is the bird at Thanksgiving. But in the UK you can expect a turkey, or perhaps even a goose (which just screams Dickensian to me, but I digress).

Sides: Traditional American sides include mashed potatoes, corn or green beans or some similar vegetable, dinner rolls, gravy, stuffing, and maybe collards and sweet potatoes (remember, I’m from the Midwest, so I can only really speak to traditions in our neck of the woods). In England the potatoes are roasted, there are parsnips and carrots, and pigs in blankets (which are actually sausages wrapped in bacon, not sausages wrapped in crescent rolls like the US version). You’ll also often find pork crackling, various chutneys, and Yorkshire puddings. Which are not pudding, but which are from Yorkshire, maybe….? Wherever they’re from, they are delicious.

mmmmm Yorkshire puddings…..

Sweet treats: Sugar cookies, more pumpkin pie and perhaps pecan can be expected at the American Christmas table. In England? Christmas pudding, which looks like a black dome-shape made of treacle and raisins/currants, among other things, covered with some cream and a sprig of holly, or Christmas cake, which is sort of a square sludge of dense sweetness. Both of them are chock-full of brandy or some other booze, and can last for, literally, years. Nothing will kill them. If you can’t tell from my lackluster descriptions, I really dislike both of these things. Although you can set a Christmas pudding on fire, which gets it a few points for presentation! I just think it’s a strange thing to have a traditional holiday treat be such a divisive one-from my own informal surveying of English folk, only about half or less actually like eating either Christmas cake or pudding. Whereas you hardly ever hear of people not liking sugar cookies! That’s just science, folks.

christmas cake vs christmas pudding

Christmas cake (L) and Christmas pudding (R)

Queen’s Speech: An important part of Christmas day in England is the Queen’s annual message. It’s pretty cut and dry-five or ten minutes and she’s outta there. But it’s a thing! And people watch! The equivalent in America is probably (American) football, although there aren’t always football games scheduled for Christmas day-like this year.

Boxing Day: I wish we had this in America, but we don’t…yet. An extra day off the day after all the Christmas festivities. As far as I can tell, most English people just use it as another day to hang out with the fam or with friends (as an antidote to all the hanging with the fam that they’ve already done). It’s nice to have that little buffer before going back to work. Personally, Jon and I will be doing a Boxing Day curry with our friends this year, after a morning spent with his grandparents.

Christmas day walk: Jon tells me it’s fairly traditional to talk a walk after Christmas lunch. I believe that-remember, English folk love walking!

Santa’s Grotto: At the mall-or shopping centre, as it’s called in the UK-kids visit Santa’s grotto, which sounds super sexy, but hopefully is not. Also, it’s Father Christmas, not Santa Claus!

Lapland: English children are told that Father Christmas and his reindeer live in Lapland, which I guess is meant to be just like the North Pole, although technically Lapland is in Finland. Either way, there’s chilly Arctic goodness.

Alright guys, these are the main comparisons that come to mind. Keep in mind, again, that I am not an expert on all American traditions (or even traditions in other parts of America!), nor am I an expert on English folk, so take all of this with a grain of salt and perhaps a shot of eggnog 🙂

And just because this is my very favorite, skin-tingling, beautiful holiday carol, I’ll leave it here for you to enjoy.

Is there anything I forgot? What sort of holiday traditions to you have? I love hearing about them!

16 thoughts on “Christmas traditions in America and England: Let’s Compare!

  1. lindsiemarie

    1. That Christmas cake/pudding stuff reminds me of fruit cake in that it lasts for years, looks like mold, and is a traditional Christmas thing. However, I don’t know any Americans who actually eat it. It’s just sort of a joke.

    2. Centre? I think you meant “center”. Unless of course you’re meaning to be French, in which case, carry on.

    3. I love Wham’s “Last Christmas” and have been listening to it non-stop. That video is full of 80’s ridic. and it reminds me of your Christmas party last year.

    4. I can’t believe it’s been nearly a year since you moved! Thank god for the internet.

    Reply
  2. Momma

    That song is my favorite to but makes me cry every time I here it! I love reading your blog it keeps me close to you . You are going to be a great mom some day. I sure love our traditions better than uk for sure haha love you

    Reply
  3. Colin

    You could probably write a very in-depth blog solely about the Panto, I’m of the view that it’s a large part of why the theatre is regarded as considerably less intimidating, artsy and ‘fancy’ in the UK than in the US – even small towns will put on some kind of panto (the Burgess Hill panto is in its 48th year!) and families from most all social backgrounds will attend. It’s a fun, silly and casual show with audience participation but it also a) ensures that a lot of small local theatres stay in business thanks to all the money they make during the two or three months around Christmas and b) introduces young kids to the concept of the theatre and that it’s a community place for everyone to go and have fun.

    My trips to the theatre in the US have been far more formal (a lot of people dress up) and seem to be regarded as something that ‘fancy’ people do, or at least that only happen in major cities. I appreciate there are some exceptions regarding formality for big Broadway shows (although with the exception of Rent there still seems to be a history of dress codes) but there’s certainly no ice cream served during the intervals which, frankly, is ridiculous and would put anyone off.

    I think most of your observations are spot-on, though obviously these things vary between families (pork crackling at Christmas? Surely a Norris thing!) things like going for a walk and eating closer to lunch time are fairly standard, I believe that Goose is considered more traditional and ‘proper’ but Turkey feeds way more people and has gradually taken over. Depictions of American Thanksgiving on imported TV shows and movies may have helped with that. As for the Queen’s speech my family never watched it until an American became a regular attendee at our Christmas Days and she insisted on it.

    The one thing I’m surprised you didn’t mention is advent calendars – I know they’ve started to catch on a lot more in the US lately but as a kid they were a key part of Christmas and it blew my mind that they weren’t standard issue in the US like they were in the UK

    Reply
  4. Evie (@ohevie)

    Christmas pickle! I still to this day have never found it first.

    We usually go see a movie Christmas afternoon as a lot of films come out Christmas day. Not sure if that’s an American thing. Honestly most of what I consider traditions are probably very specific to my family. Do other people put all the ribbons and bows on the dog as they unwrap gifts? Ha.

    Do you get gifts in stockings in the UK?

    Reply
  5. Ashley Post author

    @lindsey-you’re right about the fruitcake! i think the difference is that way more english folk seem to actually EAT christmas pudding, while American’s just laugh at it (and def don’t serve it to anyone on christmas day!) I miss you!

    @mom-america rules! haha, no but seriously. i like our traditions too:)

    @jon-yeah, but there are big sales on christmas day and the day after it too-not just delegated to january. american’s be shoppin, yo.

    @colin-thank you as always for your very detailed and fabulous response. can’t believe i forgot the advent calendar thing-totally meant to include it!

    @evie-i always wanted to go to the movies on christmas day and my mom was always like “uh, hell no”, so we’d watch dvds at our house (normally the new ones we’d just gotten). and of course everyone dresses up the dog….or they should anyway:) jon and i always do little gifts in stockings, but i dont’ know if that’s english, or just me enforcing my xmas desires on my legally bound mate. i’ll look into it!

    Reply
  6. Colin

    I think Christmas stockings are pretty standard in the UK. Certainly had them round ours.

    The best Christmas tradition in my family is ‘the sack’ – a sack of presents that Father Christmas ‘forgot’ that is wheeled out in the evening to the surprise of everyone. It goes back a few generations but as far as I know no families not directly related to my own do it. It’s the best part of Christmas.

    Movies on Christmas Day should be watched on the TV – usually a Bond film, maybe some Wallace and Gromit. Indiana Jones if you’re lucky.

    …also we have a LOT of Christmas specials on Christmas Day – Downton Abbey, Doctor Who, Top Gear – even Eastenders gets in on the act. No time for the cinema (which as Jon said will probably be closed anyway).

    Reply
  7. Domino

    I didn’t realize that crackers were British! My family has them every year. And Lindsey and I just listened to Wham! and made Christmas cookies the other day, it was awesome. Maybe I’ll get some Sherry, though, that sounds like a better idea than the milk…

    Reply
    1. Ashley Post author

      Whaaat?? Where do you guys get crackers? I’ve been wanting to bring some to my family for the past few years, but you can’t really legally travel with them. You’ll have to give me your secrets! (and get into that sherry).

      Reply
  8. Stephen Norris

    Ashley, you have so much more to learn! just a few pointers:-
    No mention of:-
    sprouts
    stuffing
    the parson’s nose

    Reply
    1. Ashley Post author

      jon just told me about the parson’s nose and that is gross stephen! however, i did not include stuffing and sprouts because that’s done in both countries (sprouts more in the UK, to be fair)!

      Reply
  9. Zhu

    Fascinating! I love cultural differences 🙂 I am both French and Canadian and I think French Christmas are more similar to British Christmas than to N. American Christmas. I find that in Canada, it’s really all about buying toys, while in France there is still a strong family eating together/food tradition. But it may have changed, I haven’t celebrated Xmas in France in ages!

    Reply
    1. Ashley Post author

      Hi Zhu! Yeah, it seems many countries don’t focus as much on gifts like the Americans (and Canadians!). When I worked in Korea a few years ago, I’d asked children what they wanted from Santa and they’d always say something adorably simple, like a pencil case or something! Thanks for chiming in! x

      Reply
  10. Pingback: our christmas | I Will See You In Far Off Places

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *